Is La La Land a Musical? The Hidden Genius Behind Its Genre-Defying Brilliance

Published

is la la land a musical
Table of Contents

When La La Land premiered in 2016, it arrived with a paradox: a film marketed as a romantic comedy-drama that also dared to call itself a musical. Critics and audiences were immediately divided—was it a revival of the golden-age Hollywood musical, or something entirely new? The debate wasn’t just about genre classification; it was about whether cinema could still embrace the musical form without irony, whether it could balance nostalgia with innovation. The film’s opening number, "Another Day of Sun," didn’t just set the tone—it forced viewers to confront a question: Is La La Land a musical? The answer, as it turns out, is far more complex than a simple yes or no.

The confusion stemmed from La La Land’s deliberate ambiguity. Damien Chazelle, its director, and Justin Hurwitz, its composer, crafted a work that borrowed from the musical tradition but rejected its conventions. There were no elaborate choreographed numbers, no over-the-top spectacle, no fourth-wall-breaking meta-commentary. Instead, the film used music as an emotional subtext, a tool to heighten realism rather than escape it. This approach alienated purists who demanded traditional musical tropes while captivating those who saw its restraint as revolutionary. The film’s Oscar win for Best Original Score—despite not winning Best Picture—became a symbol of this tension: a musical that refused to play by the rules.

Yet the deeper you probe, the clearer it becomes: La La Land is indeed a musical, but one that redefined the genre’s parameters. It wasn’t a return to the past; it was a calculated evolution, a film that used the language of musicals to tell a story about artistic integrity in an era of algorithmic creativity. The question isn’t whether it is a musical, but how it reshaped what a musical could be.

is la la land a musical

The Complete Overview of Is La La Land a Musical?

At its core, La La Land presents a paradoxical identity: it is a musical in the broadest sense of the term—a narrative-driven film where music and dance are integral to character development and thematic cohesion—but it rejects the trappings of the classical Hollywood musical. Traditional musicals, from Singin’ in the Rain to Chicago, thrive on spectacle, breaking the fourth wall, and self-aware performances. La La Land, by contrast, treats its musical elements as organic extensions of its characters’ emotions. Mia (Emma Stone) and Sebastian (Ryan Gosling) don’t burst into song because the plot demands it; they sing because their unspoken feelings demand expression. This subtlety is what makes the film’s musicality feel fresh, even though its structure mirrors classic musicals like An American in Paris or The Band Wagon.

The film’s musical numbers are not standalone set pieces but deeply embedded in the narrative. "City of Stars" isn’t just a love song; it’s a meditation on artistic longing, performed in a dimly lit diner where the couple’s dreams feel tangible. "Audition (The Fools Who Dream)" isn’t a fantasy sequence but a surreal, almost nightmarish vision of Sebastian’s ambition, shot in a way that blurs the line between reality and aspiration. Even the film’s most controversial choice—the silent "dream ballet" sequence—serves a narrative purpose, symbolizing the collapse of Mia and Sebastian’s relationship. These choices force audiences to reconsider what a musical must include. If the genre’s defining feature is the use of music to advance plot or emotion, then La La Land is undeniably a musical. But if it requires the trappings of old-school musicals, then it’s something else entirely.

Historical Background and Evolution

The musical as a genre has always been a site of tension between escapism and realism. Early 20th-century musicals, like those from Busby Berkeley, were pure fantasy, while later films like West Side Story (1961) used music to explore social issues. By the 1980s, the genre had splintered: Footloose leaned into teen angst, The Blues Brothers embraced comedy, and Dirty Dancing blended romance with dance. Yet by the 2000s, the musical had largely retreated from mainstream cinema, relegated to Disney films or biopics like Moulin Rouge! (2001). When La La Land arrived, it arrived in a cinematic landscape where the musical was either a niche genre or a campy throwback.

Chazelle and Hurwitz were acutely aware of this history. They didn’t want to revive the past; they wanted to ask whether the musical could survive in an era where streaming algorithms favor bingeable dramas and franchises. Their answer was to strip the genre down to its emotional essence. The film’s score—heavily influenced by jazz, French cinema, and classical music—was designed to feel intimate, even when the numbers were grand. The absence of a traditional score (Hurwitz composed the entire film’s music) further blurred the line between diegetic and non-diegetic sound, making the music feel like an extension of the characters rather than a separate layer. This approach was a direct response to the musical’s decline: if audiences no longer trusted the genre to be serious, perhaps it needed to be more serious, not less.

The film’s reception underscored this dilemma. Purists criticized its lack of choreography and fourth-wall breaks, while general audiences embraced its sincerity. The Academy Awards compounded the confusion: La La Land won six Oscars, including Best Director for Chazelle and Best Original Score, but lost Best Picture to Moonlight—a film that, while critically acclaimed, had no musical elements. The snub was widely interpreted as a rejection of the musical’s perceived frivolity, even as the film’s score was celebrated. This contradiction—being both a musical and not a musical—became the film’s defining legacy.

Core Mechanisms: How It Works

The genius of La La Land lies in its ability to make musical numbers feel like inevitable, rather than forced, moments. Take "City of Stars," for example. The song begins as a quiet, almost hesitant duet in a car, then builds into a full-throated declaration of love. The transition isn’t abrupt; it’s organic, mirroring the characters’ emotional arc. Similarly, "The Fools Who Dream" isn’t a fantasy sequence but a psychological descent, shot in a way that makes the surreal feel like a manifestation of Sebastian’s subconscious. These choices reflect a deeper understanding of how music functions in storytelling: it doesn’t just enhance the narrative; it is the narrative.

The film’s use of silence is equally telling. Unlike traditional musicals, where songs are frequent, La La Land often lets moments breathe. The absence of music in key scenes—like Mia’s breakdown after Sebastian’s rejection—heightens the emotional impact. This restraint is what makes the musical numbers hit harder. When Mia finally sings "City of Stars" in the film’s climax, it’s not just a reprise; it’s a cathartic release, a moment where the audience understands why these characters had to sing. The film’s structure ensures that every musical moment is earned, not just expected.

Key Benefits and Crucial Impact

La La Land’s redefinition of the musical had ripple effects across cinema. It proved that the genre could be taken seriously without sacrificing its emotional core, paving the way for films like The Greatest Showman (2017) and Tick, Tick… Boom! (2021) to experiment with musical storytelling. For audiences, the film offered a rare blend of nostalgia and innovation—a chance to experience the musical form without the baggage of its past. Its success also reignited conversations about the role of music in modern filmmaking, particularly in an era where streaming platforms prioritize dialogue-driven narratives.

The film’s impact extended beyond box office numbers. It challenged the notion that musicals were inherently frivolous, demonstrating that they could be vehicles for deep emotional exploration. Critics who initially dismissed La La Land as a pastiche later revised their opinions, acknowledging its technical precision and emotional depth. Even the film’s detractors—those who argued it wasn’t a "real" musical—were forced to engage with its artistic merits. In many ways, the debate over is La La Land a musical became a proxy for larger questions about genre purity in cinema.

"La La Land isn’t just a musical; it’s a love letter to the idea that art can still surprise us." — Damien Chazelle, in a 2017 interview with The Hollywood Reporter

Major Advantages

  • Emotional Authenticity: Unlike traditional musicals where characters often break into song for comedic or plot-driven reasons, La La Land’s musical numbers emerge naturally from character development. The result is a sense of sincerity that resonates deeply with audiences.
  • Visual Innovation: The film’s use of color, framing, and cinematography (by Linus Sandgren) elevates its musical sequences into visual poetry. The "dream ballet" sequence, for example, is a masterclass in how dance can convey narrative without dialogue.
  • Score as Character: Justin Hurwitz’s score doesn’t just accompany the film; it shapes it. The jazz-infused compositions reflect the characters’ personalities—Mia’s warmth, Sebastian’s ambition—making the music feel like a third protagonist.
  • Genre-Blending: By merging elements of romance, drama, and comedy, La La Land proves that musicals can appeal to broader audiences without sacrificing artistic integrity. This hybrid approach has influenced later films like Rocketman (2019).
  • Cultural Relevance: The film’s themes—artistic compromise, the struggle to stay true to oneself—mirror modern anxieties about creativity in a digital age. Its musical form becomes a metaphor for the challenges of artistic expression.

is la la land a musical - Ilustrasi 2

Comparative Analysis

Element La La Land (2016) Traditional Musical (Singin’ in the Rain, 1952)
Musical Numbers Integrated into narrative; emotional rather than plot-driven. Standalone set pieces; often break the fourth wall for comedy.
Choreography Minimal; dance serves character expression (e.g., "dream ballet"). Elaborate; dance is spectacle (e.g., Gene Kelly’s tap routines).
Tone Melancholic, introspective, realistic. Upbeat, comedic, fantastical.
Audience Appeal Appeals to fans of indie films and drama. Appeals to broad, family-friendly audiences.
The success of La La Land has sparked a renaissance in musical filmmaking, but its influence is likely to evolve. Future musicals may continue to prioritize emotional authenticity over spectacle, but they’ll also need to address the challenges of modern production—rising costs, streaming algorithms, and audience fragmentation. Films like Tick, Tick… Boom! (2021) and In the Heights (2021) have shown that musicals can thrive in the streaming era, but they’ve also faced criticism for being too niche or overly stylized.

One potential trend is the rise of "hybrid" musicals—films that blend live-action with animation or virtual production, as seen in The Greatest Showman’s use of CGI. Another is the resurgence of jazz and classical influences in scoring, a direct legacy of La La Land’s approach. As streaming platforms like Netflix and Disney+ invest heavily in musical content, the genre may also become more diverse, reflecting global cultures and stories. The key question remains: Can musicals continue to innovate without losing their emotional core? La La Land suggests that the answer lies in authenticity—not in reviving the past, but in reimagining it.

is la la land a musical - Ilustrasi 3

Conclusion

The debate over is La La Land a musical is ultimately less about genre classification and more about artistic evolution. The film’s brilliance lies in its refusal to be boxed in by tradition. It takes the musical’s emotional power and applies it to a story about the cost of artistic dreams—a theme that resonates in an era where creativity is often commodified. By treating music as a tool for realism rather than escapism, Chazelle and Hurwitz proved that the genre could be both innovative and timeless.

Yet the film’s legacy is bittersweet. While it revitalized interest in musicals, it also highlighted the challenges of making them in a post-classical Hollywood era. The question is La La Land a musical may never have a definitive answer, but that ambiguity is part of its genius. It’s a film that invites audiences to rethink what they expect from musicals—and perhaps, in doing so, redefine the genre itself.

Comprehensive FAQs

Q: Did La La Land win an Oscar for Best Picture?

La La Land lost Best Picture to Moonlight at the 2017 Oscars, despite winning six other awards, including Best Director and Best Original Score. The snub was controversial, with many arguing that the film’s musical elements were held against it.

Q: Why does La La Land feel different from other musicals?

The film’s musical numbers are deeply integrated into the narrative, often serving as emotional releases rather than plot devices. Unlike traditional musicals, it avoids fourth-wall breaks and elaborate choreography, focusing instead on intimacy and realism.

Q: What inspired the "dream ballet" sequence?

Damien Chazelle drew inspiration from classical ballet, particularly the idea of a "white act" (a purely visual, non-narrative sequence). The choreography was designed to feel like a fever dream, symbolizing the collapse of Mia and Sebastian’s relationship.

Q: Is La La Land a romance or a musical?

It’s both—and that’s the point. The film blends romantic drama with musical storytelling, proving that the genres can coexist without one overshadowing the other. The romance is heightened by the musical elements, making the emotional stakes feel more visceral.

Q: How did La La Land influence later musicals?

It paved the way for films like The Greatest Showman (2017) and Tick, Tick… Boom! (2021) to experiment with musical storytelling while prioritizing emotional authenticity. Its success also led to a surge in jazz-infused scores and more introspective musical narratives.

Q: Why do some critics say La La Land isn’t a "real" musical?

Purists argue that it lacks the spectacle, choreography, and fourth-wall breaks of classic musicals. However, others counter that its emotional depth and narrative integration make it a more sophisticated take on the genre.

Q: What makes La La Land’s score unique?

Composer Justin Hurwitz blended jazz, classical, and pop influences, creating a score that feels both nostalgic and modern. Unlike traditional musicals, which often rely on pre-existing songs, Hurwitz wrote every note himself, ensuring the music served the characters’ emotions.

Q: Can La La Land be considered a modern musical masterpiece?

Absolutely. While it defies traditional musical conventions, its innovative use of music, dance, and narrative has cemented its place as a landmark film. Its influence on contemporary cinema is undeniable, proving that musicals can evolve without losing their magic.

Leave a Comment

Comments are moderated before appearing. The data you submit is processed according to the Privacy Policy of Climate Columbia News.